That The UK Should Have a Written Constitution

The proposition is that the United Kingdom should adopt a written constitution, explicitly outlining the rights of citizens, the roles of all organs of the government, and the powers (and limitations thereon) of the state.  The choice facing the country is therefore whether to adopt the sort of explicit, formal supreme law typified by documents such as the United States Constitution.  The alternative is to retain the status quo of its constitution consisting of a variety of informal codes and conventions, many of them unwritten, which guide the political and legal culture of the country.  As it stands, parliament enjoys “sovereignty,” whereby it may pass whatever laws it wishes with no higher law limiting its legislation nor any judicial power to question the fundamental legitimacy of the law.  Adopting such a constitution would restrict the behavior of the government, and subject all exercises of state power to judicial review. In 2007 then Prime Minister Gordon Brown made proposals for a British constitution and bill of rights which would have restricted the powers of the prime minister in areas such as declaring war[1] however these proposals never came to anything.

 

Bibliography 

Dren Doli and Fisnik Korenica, "A Comparison Between Judicial Review Models", Group for Legal and Political Studies, August 2009. Paul Franz, 'Unconstitutional and Outlawed Political Parties: A German-American Comparison', Boston College International and Comparative Law Review, 5 51 (1982) p.51 Christian Fraser, "France Sends Roma Gypsies Back to Romania", BBC News, 20th August 2010.Lord Scarman, "Why Britain Needs a Written Constitution", Charter88, 20th July 1992. Greg Winter, "Judge Orders Billions in Aid to City Schools", New York Times, 15th February 2005.Will Woodward et al., "PM offers to hand power to the people in constitution debate", The Guardian, 4th July 2007, accessed 29/6/11."Government Commits to Seeking a Ban of the Extreme Right-Wing National Democratic Party of Germany (NPD)", 1 German Law Journal (2000). "The British Constitution" Icons a portrait of England. BBC News, "DNA Database 'Breach of Rights'", 4th December 2008, accessed 29/6/11. England and Wales High Court, 'Thoburn vs. Sunderland City Council' EWHC 195, (2002).OECD, "Constitutions of Central and Eastern European Countries and the Baltic States", Sigma Papers No.2 (1995).Statewatch, 'ASBOwatch monitoring the use of Anti-Social Behavior Orders', September 2004. The Canadian Encyclopedia, "Harper, Elijah", Institute Historica-Dominion, accessed 29/6/11.Supreme Court of the United States, "Citizens United vs. Federal Election Commission", Legal Information Institute. UK Parliament, 'Anti-social Behaviour Act 2003', The National Archives, 20th November 2003.

X