This House believes science is a threat to humanity

Science is the accumulation of knowledge in a systematic method to create general truths on the operation of the universe, most commonly referring to “the physical world and its phenomena, the nature, constitution, and forces of matter, the qualities and functions of living tissues.” (Webster’s)1 In this debate it can be understood to be the development and utilisation of new technology and the expansion of human knowledge in the modern era, though it should be noted that not all technological advances are from rigorous scientific analysis (such as the industrial revolution) and science has only significantly influenced technology in the last two centuries.2 What it means to be human is itself another debate, but here it can be understood to be both the collective entity of the human race and the defining features of humans which make them distinguishable from other beings.

Advancements in science have occurred for thousands of years as far back as the Ancient Greeks (who many believe invented scientific principles),3and their effects are becoming ever more pronounced. Production has shifted to mechanized factories and even killing in warfare is being replaced in parts with unmanned drones. The boundaries of medicine are being expanded with possibilities of cloning and stem cell research. Science has allowed acts that would otherwise be impossible for humans to consider undertaking. It has created previously unknown abilities to heal the sick or destroy all of humanity with Weapons of Mass Destruction.

This debate questions whether or not being able to undertake those acts is a benefit, and whether science does more to improve lives or harm them. Whilst this debate is on the principle in question, a proposition could practically propose that society hold public debates about the implications of issues such as genetic engineering, with possible moratoriums following.



Association of Reproductive Health Professionals, ‘Brochures of Patients: Human Cloning and Genetic Modification,’ , Accessed 30.08.11Avert, “HIV Drugs: Vaccines and Animal Testing,” Accessed 08.09.11BBC, ‘England Riots: Government mulls social media controls,’ 2011, , Accessed 30.08.11BBC, ‘Ethics guide: Possible Moral Positions,’ , Accessed 30.08.11BBC, ‘The Amish,’ , Accessed 30.08.11Business Inside, ‘The UK is Considering Twitter, Social Media After Huge Riots,’ , Accessed 30.08.11  City of Sydney, ‘Indigenous History of Sidney City,’ , Accessed 30.08.11Cox, Judy. ‘An Introduction to Marx’s Theory of Alienation,’ International Socialism. Issue 79, 1998. , Accessed, ‘Definitions of Science,’  Accessed 30.08.11Department for Environment Food and Rural Affairs, ‘Causes of Air Pollution,’ , Accessed, ‘Propaganda and the News,’ 2001, ,  Accessed 30.08.11  HistoryLink, ‘U.S. Army defeats Native Americans at Battle of Four Lakes on September 1, 1858,’ 2003, , Accessed  30.08.11Krishna, S.M., ‘Development in India, China has world-wide effect,’ Business Standard, 11 April 2010 , Accessed 30.08.11Gilboa, Eytan. ‘The CNN Effect: The Search for a Communication Theory of International Relations.’ Political Communication. 22:27-44. 2005. , Accessed 30.08.11Los, Maria. ‘The Technologies of Total Domination.’ Surveillance and Society. 2 (1): 15-38. 2004. , Accessed 30.08.11Making the Modern World, ‘World War One/Deadlock,’ , Accessed 30.08.11Medicine Encyclopedia, ‘Mortality in the Twentieth and Twenty-First Centuries,’ , Accessed 30.08.11New York Time, ‘Surveillance of Citizens by Government,’ , Accessed 30.08.11Nuclear Age Peace Foundation, ‘Consequences of Using Nuclear Weapons,’ 1997, ,  Accessed 30.08.11Nuclear Age Peace Foundation, ‘Mutual Assured Destruction,’ , Accessed 30.08.11Oxfam, “There is enough food to feed the world,” 2011 , Accessed 08.09.11People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals, ‘Animal Testing 101,’ , Accessed 30.08.11Psychology Today, ‘How to Be Happier,’ 2011, , Accessed 30.08.11Scientists for Global Responsibility, ‘Genetics and Ethics,’ , Accessed 30.08.11Stop Huntingdon Animal Cruelty, ‘Introduction to Shac,’, Accessed 30.08.11The Atlantic, ‘Is Google Making Us Stupid?’ 2008, , Accessed 30.08.11The Metrowest Daily News, ‘Renewable Energy faces difficulties,’ 2010, , Accessed 30.08.11The Telegraph, ‘The Government is creating a surveillance state,’ , Accessed 30.08.11Wikipedia, ‘Human Evolution: Use of Tools,’ , Accessed 30.08.11Wolpert, Lewis. ‘Is Science Dangerous?’ Nobel Symposium. NS 120. 2002. , Accessed 30.08.11World Centric, ‘Environmental Destruction,’ , Accessed 30.08.11World Hunger, 2011, ‘2011 World Hunger and Poverty Facts and Statistics,’ , Accessed 30.08.11Union of Concerned Scientists “Global Warming,” Union of Concerned Scientists: Citizens and Scientists for Environmental Solutions Accessed 08.09.11Verwimp, Philip. ‘Machetes and Firearms: The Organization of Massacres in Rwanda.’ 43:5. 2006. , Accessed 30.08.11‘Source List and Detailed Death Tolls for the Primary Megadeaths of the Twentieth,’ 2011, ,  Accessed 30.08.11“Ancient Greece: Science and Medicine,” Discovery Channel Accessed 08/09/11


Or log in with...