Discussion

DIN debate: This House believes that socialism in Europe is dead

6 replies [Last post]

DIN debate: This House believes that socialism in Europe is dead

Alex Helling's picture
Offline
Joined: 13 Sep 2011
Posts: 774
Applause: 49

After narrowly gaining enough seats in last week's general election to form a coalition government Greece's ruling coalition- made up of the centre right New Democracy party, the PASOK party and Democratic Left Alliance- announced a new economic austerity plan for the country on Friday. Following intense public pressure and more than a year of civil disorder, the Greek government is due to approach the EU with a plan to cut its national debt that includes increased support for Greek citizens hit hard by a collapse of investor confidence in the economy of the south European state.

Although heavy spending on public projects and labour laws favorable to unions and state workers did a lot to increase living standards in Greece over the last two decades, the financial collapse has put the Greek state under pressure to cut public services, increase tax rates and liberalise its economy, a conservative approach to economic recovery that many Greeks object to. New Democracy and its partners faced a significant challenge during the June election from Syriza, an alliance of a wide range of Greek socialist, ecosocialist and community political parties. The startling popular appeal of Syriza has sparked talk of a similar revival among Europe's other left wing parties, which moved quickly toward the political centre-ground in the last years of the twentieth century; left wing parties throughout the EU have been criticised for failing to provide compelling alternatives to the austerity policies that have been enforced by the EU's leadership and most influential member states.

IDEA will be looking into the state of Greece and the future of socialism in Europe in greater depth during a public debate that will be taking place on Wednesday 27 June. Hosted by City and Islington Sixth Form College, Young People Explore Europe's Future will showcase speeches by A-level students who have received debate training as part of IDEA's Debate in the Neighbourhood initiative. The debate will address the motion "This House believes that socialism in Europe is dead". The debate's panel will be made up of six City and Islington students, who will be joined by two veterans of socialist politics in the UK. The debate's audience will also have the opportunity to offer questions and floor speeches. Look out for video highlights of the event on ideabte.org from 28 June. For more information about Debate in the Neighbourhood, email acavell@idebate.org.uk or visit din.idebate.org

Feel free to discuss and give your opinion either on the topic of the debate, the situation in Greece, or the DIN event itself.

For more information on the topic read http://idebate.org/debatabase/debates/philosophical-political-theory/house-believes-socialism-dead

47 weeks 1 day ago
KateDebate's picture
Offline
Joined: 27 Mar 2012
Posts: 148
Applause: 11

The left seems to have done quite well in several recent elections in France and in Greece.

47 weeks 23 hours ago
Colin Helling's picture
Offline
Joined: 13 Sep 2011
Posts: 152
Applause: 8

Doing well in elections is one thing, but can socialism be sustained through austerity? The French socialists are still committed to cutting the defecit, even if softened with a stimulus and possibly a little growth. Basically for the answer to this look to France in a year or two!

47 weeks 22 hours ago
booji's picture
Offline
Joined: 20 Mar 2012
Posts: 369
Applause: 26

Despite the lack of a coherent response from the left with the financial crisis so recently I dont think it could be said that socialism is dead as it is once more obvious that there needs to be another option apart from capitalism. Or at very least there needs to be a more social grounding to capitalism. Whether it will mean a long term revival of socialism who knows?

47 weeks 16 hours ago
Alastair Stevens's picture
Offline
Joined: 21 Mar 2012
Posts: 118
Applause: 11

Ideologies dont die, they are simply reborn in new guises. If the left dissapeared someone would create it because 'fairness' is a pretty fundamental concept that everyone can believe. So long as there is a capitalist system with inequality some people will always advocate a need for the system to be fairer no matter how misguided that may be if put into practice.

46 weeks 4 days ago
Alex Helling's picture
Offline
Joined: 13 Sep 2011
Posts: 774
Applause: 49

This is only the case so long as the underlying theory remains sound and relevant. Take for example Physiocracy, an economic theory developed in France, which has sunk without much trace but could well have been the foundation for an ideology just like Smith's wealth of nations is. Unfortunately they created a theory that may have been relevant to the 17th and 18th Centuries just as the industrial revolution was getting going. I however dont think that the underlying ideas behind socialism are about to go out of date or become redundant.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Physiocracy

46 weeks 22 hours ago
Emaraude's picture
Offline
Joined: 2 Nov 2012
Posts: 2
Applause: 0

Several movements of ideologies have developed over the years. It emphasized the differences of concepts and ideals among people.

 

28 weeks 2 days ago
Syndicate content