Debates: Free Speech Debate

8 Apr 2013

Reverence and veneration of the national flag has long been profound in the United States, possibly more so than in many other countries. This reverence has led many state legislatures as well as the federal Congress to pass legislation banning the burning of the flag. Such legislation generally...

18 Feb 2013

The case: Punishing users of extremist websites

On 15th March 2012, Mohammed Merah killed two soldiers of the French army and left a third in a coma. A few days later, on 19th March, Merah attacked a Jewish school in Toulouse shooting at point blank range a teacher and three children. It...

18 Feb 2013

The case: Netherlands passed Europe's first net neutrality legislation

On 8 May 2012 the senate of the Netherlands approved amendments to its Telecommunications Act (unofficial translation ...

15 Feb 2013

Rupert Murdoch’s News Corporation is a multinational media corporation with interests in books, cable and satellite television, films, magazines, newspapers and websites. It is influential around the world and in its portfolio News Corporation includes very influential channels and...

7 Jan 2013

Why the Arab world needs community radio

Social media and satellite television played a crucial role in the Arab uprisings, but Daoud Kuttab argues community radio must be embraced to effect...

7 Jan 2013

The case: (Not) reporting homosexuality in the Middle East

Homosexuality is a taboo subject mainstream Arabic news outlets regularly avoid. If reported at all, stories typically address homosexuality as a foreign phenomenon or loathsome disease unique to the west. Journalist Brian...

4 Jan 2013

The Supreme Court’s ruling in Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission[1] held that the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, which protects freedom of speech, prohibited the government from putting restrictions on independent...

3 Jan 2013

History reclassified as state secret: the case of Xu Zerong

In 2002, historian Xu Zerong was sentenced to 13 years in jail for leaking state secrets. The classification of the ...

21 Dec 2012

Does money have the right to speak?

The US supreme court's decision on Citizens United raises a vital issue: should corporations have the same free speech rights as individuals? Brian Pellot discusses the case.

The case

Citizens United v Federal...

11 Dec 2012

Religion is largely ignored from foreign policy and from literature about how foreign policy should be determined. Religious freedom is likewise for the most part ignored and sidelined. Most countries where religion is a factor in foreign policy are promoting a particular religion rather than...

7 Dec 2012

A university of less-than-liberal arts?

Should Yale University refuse to operate in Singapore where human rights and free expression face significant restrictions? Katie Engelhart weighs the arguments for and against.

The case

In March 2011, Yale University...

7 Dec 2012

Freedom of speech is often considered to be one of the most basic tenets of democracy. As a fundamental right it is enshrined in documents such as the Bill of Rights in the United States, the United Nations Declaration of Human Rights, and the European Convention on Human Rights: Congress shall...

4 Dec 2012

The case: The Israeli Whistleblower

Journalist Anat Kamm was sentenced to four and a half years in October 2011 for leaking 2,000 classified military documents obtained during her service with the Israeli Defence Force (IDF). The documents, which were leaked to Haaretz reporter Uri Blau...

23 Nov 2012

The case: Teaching creationism in US schools

On April 11 2012, Tennessee passed a law that will protect teachers who choose to explore the merits of creationism alongside theories of evolution in public school science classes. Governor Bill Haslam claimed that the legislation would not...

23 Nov 2012

This debate will in large part be focused in the UK. At the time of writing, press freedom in the United Kingdom has become a significant issue as a result of the phone tapping scandal and the subsequent...

23 Nov 2012

The Case: Pussy Riot, Putin's Russia and the Orthodox Church

Was punk band Pussy Riot’s anti-Putin performance in a Moscow church 'religious hatred hooliganism' or an artistic form of political dissent? Olga Shvarova considers the case.

On 21 February 2012, the all-...

23 Nov 2012

The case: The Mexican journalist and the "alcoholic" president

Mexican journalist Carmen Aristegui was fired for publicly calling on President Felipe Calderón to clarify rumours that he suffered from alcoholism, writes Felipe Correa. 

In February 2011, the well-...

15 Nov 2012

The case: The private life of a national hero

To mark the 70th anniversary of the death of the Turkish Republic’s founder, Kemal Atatürk, in November 2008, journalist and documentary filmmaker Can Dündar set out to produce, “The complete story of Atatürk [which] has been told neither to...

14 Nov 2012

The case: The Japanese New History Textbook controversy

A textbook entitled New History Textbook (Atarashii Rekishi Kyokasho) was published by a committee consisting of conservative scholars in 2000, and was approved as a social science textbook for junior high schools by the ministry of...

14 Nov 2012

The case: Zuma and his spear

In May 2012, South Africa’s president, Jacob Zuma, turned to the courts to ban a painting, which showed him fully clothed but with his genitals exposed. The case was brought against ...

14 Nov 2012

The case: Is pro-terrorist speech a crime? Massachusetts says so

Tarek Mehanna is a 29-year-old American citizen and pharmacologist who was raised in Sudbury, a quiet suburb of Boston, Massachusetts in the US. Trouble began for Mehanna in 2004, when he travelled to Yemen. Mehanna insists...

13 Nov 2012

The case: Julian Assange: a journalist?

In February 2010, Wikileaks, a clandestine whistleblower outlet, released the first in a series...

13 Nov 2012

The case: The Jaipur Literature Festival

Salman Rushdie, the Booker prize-winning author of Midnight’s Children as well and The Satanic Verses, which is banned in many countries including India, was slated to attend the Jaipur...

13 Nov 2012

The case study: Censoring hip-hop music in London

“Guns, bitches and bling were never part of the four elements of hip hop and never will be.” Scroobius Pip, ‘Thou Shalt Always Kill

Recurrent themes in discussions on popular culture are the origins and impact of...

13 Nov 2012

The case study: England’s last blasphemy trial

Blasphemy is the act of showing contempt or speaking offensively about a deity or of persons and symbols regarded as sacred by the followers of a specific religion. The concept of blasphemy is mostly associated with the Abrahamic...

13 Nov 2012

The Case: Jerry Springer & Blasphemous libel

BBC television’s broadcast of Jerry Springer: The Opera in January 2005 was met with protests by Christian groups. Speaking to the BBC, one protester said, “There...

13 Nov 2012

The case: Blasphemy law and violence in Pakistan

In June 2009, Aasia Bibi, a Christian woman and mother-of-five from a village in the Sheikhupura district in Pakistan, got into an argument with fellow villagers who accused her of polluting the water in a well by touching it as a non-...

12 Nov 2012

The discussion: Guilt by association: the London 2012 Olympics

The drive to control all references to the Olympic Games is part of a global creep of intellectual property law that has led...

12 Nov 2012

The discussion: Has Innocence of Muslims ended the innocence of YouTube?

The fact that Google, which owns YouTube, has voluntarily blocked the Islamophobic ...