Discussion

Hooligans should not be punished so harsh as is being done now. ~Opinions~

2 replies [Last post]

Hooligans should not be punished so harsh as is being done now. ~Opinions~

Bram Middelkamp's picture
Offline
Joined: 15 May 2012
Posts: 2
Applause: 1

Hooligans should not be punished so harsh as is being done now.

Nowadays in the Netherlands the government actively prosecutes hooligans, they have to pay high fine’s, get community service or sometimes even jail time. In some cases I can agree with thins but the striking point which is absolutely ridiculous to me is that they are shown on national television. Their faces and when the police knows their name they will also tell the entire country about it.

This last point is a method of the police they don’t even use when an ‘ordinary’ murder has been committed. So while murderers and rapists stay unknown, some hooligans are being shown to the country and presented like they are wild animals.

Every weekend I go to the match of the local football club and I know some boys from our firm and they are very normal people, sometimes they are taken by their emotions and do something stupid.

But should we take away the privacy of those people instead of the privacy of murderers and rapists?

 

I think that we are solving the problem of hooliganism on the wrong way. Now hooligans meet on the day before the match so we’re not even solving the problem, but just moving it instead.

 

How do you all feel about the measures the Dutch government has taken against hooligans?

I’m looking forward to your opinions!

1 year 1 week ago
Alastair Stevens's picture
Offline
Joined: 21 Mar 2012
Posts: 118
Applause: 11

Murderers and other serious offenders should obviously not be punished less than hooligans. However this does not mean that hooligans should not be punished. Paying fines and community service is fair and fits the punishment as it can help pay for the cost of the damage they have caused and the cost of policing their actions. Jail time is necessary for those who cause physical harm in the process of their hooliganism, again this is a proportionate response.

'Naming and shaming' is a slightly different issue. Presumably the intention is to counteract the fact that hooligans move around and cause trouble in many different places (as the matches move around) so that everyone knows who they are so making them more likely to be reported. It also helps to act to deter them from these actions.

I dont know about the in the Netherlands but murder and rape trials are usually widely reported so there is no need for the police to mount a naming and shaming campaign as journalists will pick it up without police encouragement.

 

1 year 1 week ago
Michael Smith's picture
Offline
Joined: 6 Nov 2012
Posts: 8
Applause: 0

I will agree on this. This is really nice. I love the idea and the concept on this. 

 

28 weeks 3 days ago
Syndicate content